Laura Hershey: Writer, Poet, Activist, Consultant Rotating Header Image

Laura’s Labor Day Weekend Column

Labor Day means different things to different people.

The Labor Day Telethon

For me, it’s hard (try as I might) to escape the association between Labor Day and the Jerry Lewis Muscular Dystrophy Association Telethon. Though it’s been several years since we’ve organized a direct action protest, the Internet continues to provide us with opportunities to educate and inoculate people against the Telethon’s pity paradigm.

The Internet also provides us with more evidence of the hypocrisy of a man who claims to be a “humanitarian” (and of a shallow showbiz industry that validated that title with a 2008 “Humanitarian Oscar Award.”) During a recent interview on Inside Edition, Jerry Lewis avowed that he would punish Lindsay Lohan physically for her recent transgressions. “I’d smack her in the mouth if I saw her. I would smack her in the mouth and be arrested for abusing a woman! I would say, ‘You deserve this and nothing else’ — whack! And then if she’s not satisfied, I’d put her over my knee and spank her.” If you want to torture yourself by watching it for yourself, here’s the video clip.

(Some people, perhaps tired of the media coverage of Lohan’s nonsense, seem to find Lewis’ statements funny. But my philosopher crip friend Joe Stramondo puts them in perspective: “Jerry Lewis again uses a narrative that masquerades violence/oppression as ‘help’ by obscuring it with pity. This time it’s women who he pities. So, I guess sexism and ableism have something in common for him.”

I would recommend avoiding Jerry Lewis and the Telethon altogether this weekend. For an edifying alternative, check out my friend Mike Ervin’s sassy response to the Telethon. He made a video called The Kids Are All Right (long before the current lesbian family dramedy), about the activist group Jerry’s Orphans.

By the way, check out the Denver Post on Tuesday for a spot-on column describing disability activists’ objections to the Telethon.

Labor Force Diversity (Including Disability)

This Labor Day, too many people are still jobless, and the situation is worse for people with disabilities. In August 2010, only 22 percent of people with disabilities were participating in the labor force, while 70.2 percent of non-disabled people were in the labor force. The unemployment rate for those with disabilities was 15.6 percent, compared with 9.3 percent for persons with no disability.

There are many complex reasons for this disparity. Certainly one reason are the negative attitudes that some employers and coworkers have toward people with disabilities. Even those who are not actively hostile to disabled folks may not have considered or understood the need to actively recruit, hire, and accommodate workers with disabilities.

To try to address the lack of awareness, the U.S. Department of Labor (which provided the above statistics) sponsors National Disability Employment Awareness Month (NDEAM). This year, I have a direct role in this effort. A few lines of my poetry, along with a piece of my digital art, appear on the official poster for NDEAM. The poster is available for FREE to employers, advocacy organizations, schools, or anyone else who requests it. Even cooler, it’s available in eight languages, including Navajo and Lakota. Go to the DOL website at to order or download your poster(s). Did I mention they’re FREE?

Can a public awareness campaign like this make a real difference in improving disabled people’s employment prospects? Who knows? But I think the poster turned out beautifully, and I like the emphasis on disability as a part of diversity. I also know that the DOL under President Obama is being managed by some hard-working, progressive people, including Secretary Hilda Solis; and Kathy Martinez, Assistant Secretary for the Office of Disability Employment Policy.

(And I should probably add that my comments above about MDA and Jerry Lewis have no official government endorsement!)

Labor in Service of Independent Living

Labor Day celebrates workers, and my favorite workers are those who support people with disabilities in living in the community. Call them attendants, personal care assistants (PCAs), personal assistants (PAs), home health aides, helpers, even certified nurses’ aides (CNAs) – whatever you call them, they are crucial to the disability rights movement.

Good attendants do more than just enable a disabled person to live outside an institution. They allow us to live a life of maximum independence, functioning at our own personal best and working toward our life goals.

In just the past few months, here are just some of the ways that home care workers have made a huge difference for my health and/or independence and/or work:

  • Last week my wheelchair sip-and-puff mechanism started malfunctioning, to the point that I could not drive it. I had several important work meetings coming up in the following days, that I was afraid I would have to miss. My attendant Suzi figured out where the leak was, and fixed it temporarily until the right tube was restored. (On top of being an excellent PCA, Suzi is usually my fix-it person when the wheelchair repair company doesn’t return my phone calls!)
  • In August, I spent an amazing week in Los Angeles at the 2010 Lambda Literary Retreat (fondly called “queer writers’ camp”). Cara and Mallorie accompanied me, and they both did an extraordinary job of supporting me so I could get the most out of the opportunity. They creatively found and processed food I could eat safely. They worked hurried morning shifts and late-night shifts so I could attend workshops and social events. They gave me space and silence within which to write poetry, while making sure I got my physical needs met. When the airline misplaced one of my ventilators, they cut and taped an ill-fitting tube to make the other ventilator serve temporarily.
  • For nearly a year, Krista has shown up every weekday morning, as early as I need her to, enabling me to supervise my daughter in getting ready for school. Any instability in this schedule could be disastrous for my family. But unlike in some earlier years, these days I never go to bed worrying about a morning cancellation or no-show.

    All of my current attendants are great – highly competent, reliable, smart, cooperative, and calm amidst craziness. And I have enough experience under my belt to know how hard life can be when that’s not the case. (Attendant horror stories belong in another blog post.)

    Another whole column – or a whole book – could be devoted to discussing the labor rights, or lack thereof, of home care workers. Given what they do, they are for the most part underpaid, uninsured, and unsupported by society as a whole. They usually don’t get paid sick days or vacation days. In only a few states do they have union representation.

    So many entities make inflated profits by exploiting our disability-related needs. But the people doing the real, hard work that helps us live independently don’t get nearly enough. People with disabilities and our support workers need to organize together, to demand fairer policies and more resources for this work.

    For now, though, I’ll use Labor Day as a day to express my appreciation for these indispensable workers.

    The End of Summer

    Labor Day also represents the end of summer, if not officially, then at least traditionally. My most recent “Life Support” blog post for the Reeve Foundation website describes one of the highlights of my summer. Surf on over there and read “Roughing It, Accessibly, in a Colorado Yurt.” And while you’re there, check out the other great bloggers, articles, and information.


    1. Julie Weber says:

      Really nice article, Laura, and I love that your work is on the Poster. Thank you 🙂

    2. Stephen Hand says:

      Wonderful. God bless you are your important life! I want to read more after seeing this referenced at NDY!

    3. Laura –

      Thank You for all your thoughtful comments this labor day. Your thoughts on Jerry Lewis are without need for any further comment.

      I was especially in-tune with your comments on personal assistants and the invaluable work they do for us, people with disabilities! I feel exactly as you that the good ones are so valuable, and so under-paid and often under-appreciated. I personally make sure to thank my PAs every chance I get. But that doesn’t make their financial and personal well-being any better, except to know they’ve done a job well-done. So what are current actions we can take? What is being done to correct this wrong and change the way PAs are seen, paid, and appreciated?

      Thanks for doing what you do, and saying what you say,
      Jason Gallagher

    4. Wendy says:

      I am one of “Jerry’s Kid’s”. I have myasthenia gravis. I can see a regular neuro with Medicaid, but as soon as that doc found out I can go to clinic and be covered, he switched me from private patient to clinic patient. I guess he gets paid more that way.

      I have to admit to being bummed out! I wish there was more help. Sometimes I feel sooooooo trapped! I can walk thanks to the help of my service dog…but not well and not for long. I wish someone like me could qualify for a scooter. I can only shop at places with their own electric scooters and have never shopped in the local downtown area which is hilly and full of small inaccessible stores.

      I always kept in the back of my mind that MDA could get me a wheelchair. Now they don’t even do that. I had one donated to me a few years ago that became a nightmare. It broke regularly. Neither the independent living organization nearby or the MDA would help to fix it. Finally I donated it to a guy who fixes them up for folks. He would not fix it up for my use, though.

      The cracks in the system are VERY large. Just like every national organization, the MDA has become a way for administrators and docs to supplement their income, not an organization dedicated to really helping disabled folks. Bummer 🙁

      I am sooooooooooooo thankful for my health aide!!!!!!! She is one of the best things that has ever happened 🙂

    5. Cait says:

      Your attendents sound AWESOME.

      I’m in the process of trying to find and figure out funding for a staff attendent of some sort who can help me with housecare/cleanliness and organizing self care. I have an autism spectrum disorder and my executive functioning is such that it’s incredibly difficult to live successfully independently. I am 30 and I recieve SSDI but have relied on my parents’ previously to cover the additional help I need. However, I am growing increasingly tired of the additional ‘strings attached’ that go along with that- not strings of ‘do this for us because we love you and need it’ but ‘do this because you are grateful’.

    6. […] of people are, as always, posting about the MDA Telethon this Labor Day weekend (I recommend this piece by Laura Hershey). Usually the focus is on smashing the negative images (pity) that the MDA Telethon often conveys, […]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You can add images to your comment by clicking here.